How can [a] Grand Lodge, in any way that can be considered within the framework of our tenets, justify the attempt to silence a brother for holding personal opinions and communicating them? Where would Henry Coil, Albert Mackey, Albert Pike, and Carl Claudy be if THEIR Grand Masters had silenced them?
At the passing of Brother Dunn, like many across the virtual and real Masonic community, I felt saddened. Sad because a great voice for the perseverance of the fraternity that we all love had fallen silent. In my reflecting on Br. Dunn, I realized that he was not done communicating to us, and that I wanted to publish one last thought that many may not of been aware of.
The following is from the recently published book "
The Freethinking Freemason" by Br. Tim Bryce, published by Cornerstone Publishers. In Br. Bryce's book is an introduction by Brother Dunn. Though specificially written to introduce Br. Bryce's book, I think it stands as testament to Br. Dunn's metal. And as such, it is a worthy thing to make sure that all who knew him have the opportunity to read it.
The Following is reprinted, with permission, from Brother Tim Bryce.
THE PROBLEM WITH WR. TIM BRYCEby W
:.Tim Bryce, PM, MPS, MBBFMN
timb001@phmainstreet.comPalm Harbor, Florida, USA
"A Foot Soldier for Freemasonry"TIM'S NOTE: "Earlier this week, we lost W:.Bro. R. Theron Dunn, PM, to the G.A.O.T.U. His passing was premature and he will be missed by those of us who have corresponded with him over the years. Few know that in addition to his other Masonic accomplishments, including the Editor of the "Lodgeroom International," he was also honored last year for his endeavors in promoting Masonic Education which earned him membership in the coveted Masonic Brotherhood of the Blue Forget-Me-Not. I have had the privilege of knowing him for the last few years where we got to know each other well. Not long ago he wrote the following piece on me which I have also used as the intro to my new book. I believe the piece says a lot about his attitude towards the fraternity. I hope you enjoy it."
by W:.Theron Dunn, PM
Editor, "The Lodgeroom International"
February 2007
I first became aware of the writings of Worshipful Tim Bryce a couple of years ago when
he was producing his "Freemasonry for the Next Generation" eZine and his "Masonic Update" podcast. Unfortunately about the same time, both of these valuable resources came to an abrupt halt. In December 2005, by order of the Grand Master of Florida, at the time M:.W:.John Kavanaugh.
Most Worshipful Kavanaugh took offense at Wr. Bryce's articles, particularly his "Masonic Manifesto" which outlined several ideas for improving the fraternity. M:.W:.Kavanaugh's censorship of Worshipful Bryce baffled many of us and resulted in an outcry to rescind the order. This outpouring of support for Wr. Bryce was ignored by Grand Master Kavanaugh.
As a result of the order, Wr. Bryce sought and found several other venues which allowed him to continue to publish his Masonic articles, all of which seek to improve the fraternity, not to destroy it. The Lodgeroom International Magazine, recognizing the value in Wr. Bryce's efforts, has published many of his articles for the benefit of Freemasonry.
Everything seemed to settle in to a Status Quo until Wr. Bryce took a stand on the recognition of Prince Hall. Then, in December 2006, Wr. Bryce received another letter from the current Grand Master, Most Worshipful Robert Trump. Like the previous instruction, M:.W:.Trump instructed Wr. Bryce to cease and desist his weekly e-mail bulletins regarding his work.
M:.W:.Trump's letter alluded to claims having been made to other grand jurisdictions that accused Wr. Bryce of being an Internet spammer. Consequently, the Grand Master used this as a basis to order him to cease and desist such broadcasts. Each e-mail that Wr. Bryce had sent included a means of removing the recipient from further communications, and everyone that had requested to be removed, had been.
On the surface, it appears Wr. Bryce is the center of a controversy in Florida. On the Internet, he has been called on more than one occasion "egotistical," a "self-promoter," "pompous," etc. His defenders, on the other hand, welcome his writings and laud him with praise and support. One has to wonder what this is all about and why he receives all of this attention. Having followed these events over the last year, and having corresponded and talked with Wr. Bryce, perhaps I can shed some light as to what is going on.
The key to understanding our Brother from Florida is his background.
First, Wr. Bryce comes from a long line of Freemasons. His father and grandfather were raised Master Masons under the Grand Lodge of New York, and the family traces their roots back to Scotland. He has been a Master Mason for ten years, and in that time has been very active in his lodge and Freemasonry in general. He has gone through the chairs of his Lodge and served as Worshipful Master and as Secretary.
Wr. Bryce served as President of his local Masters & Wardens Association, and as Zone and District Chairman for Public Relations for the Grand Lodge of Florida. Wr. Bryce has also further served the Grand Lodge of Florida as editor of the "Florida Mason," the Grand Lodge's official publication. Wr. Bryce is a member of the Philalethes Society, the well known and respected Masonic research group.
His efforts did not go unnoticed. As a result of his diligent efforts on behalf of the fraternity, Wr. Bryce was awarded membership in the Masonic Brotherhood of the Blue Forget Me Not (an honorary society for Masonic Education), and he was made a Knight Zuri by the Knights of Freemasonry Universal.
Professionally, Wr. Bryce works as a management consultant specializing in methodologies for systems development. For the last 30 years he has traveled the globe consulting with companies of all sizes and shapes to cleanup their systems development practices. There are plenty of tools and experts for cleaning up computer programs, but if you want to bring order out of the chaos in a major information system project, Bryce is your man.
Bryce's professional career involves considerable training and writing pertaining to management and computer related topics. His book, "The IRM Revolution: Blueprint for the 21st Century" (co-written with his father) made it to the Top 10 list for management related books in Japan. He has also developed a long list of articles over the years making him a past master of the short essay. Between his persona and his ability to generate articles, one begins to understand his style of writing which some describe as "brutally frank." To some, this is refreshing; to some critics, he has been described as too bold and too outspoken for his own good.
My experience with Wr. Bryce has shown me that it is his professional background and enthusiasm for the fraternity that drives him. Wr. Bryce has developed a reputation as a no-nonsense type, a man who may not be politically correct, but knows how to get the job done.
So why has Wr. Bryce drawn the wrath of at least two Grand Masters in the Grand Lodge of Florida? I think it's because he is not afraid to speak his mind and challenge the status quo. He is a good Mason, one who is not afraid to follow his obligation to the fraternity, to point out problems, and to offer solutions. His writings make us stop, think, and examine. More though, he does not simply point out problems, he offers thoughtful and insightful solutions.
He has told me that it is not important that people agree with him, but rather he wants them to stop, engage their minds, and seek further light. He openly admits that he doesn't have all of the answers. On the other hand, he considers it critical that we be allowed to discuss them as Masons within the rightful constraints of our obligations. One thing he has said numerous times, "If there is anything constant in life, it is change." He once told me that he doesn't believe in criticizing something unless you can offer an alternative, which he regularly does.
Between Wr. Bryce's professional and Masonic background, he brings a lot to the table. People can accuse him of many things, but in my experience, he cannot be accused of not being fair, honest and courteous. In a word, a Masonic example.
Which brings us to the nub of the problem. Wr. Bryce has developed a reputation as a "straight shooter," and has become what many weak managers fear, an "unofficial leader." We have all seen it happen, where one member of the group, with more experience or insight leads the group because the "official" leadership is unsure, weak, or so out of touch the group has lost the will to follow.
It is the opinion of this Mason that Wr. Bryce, through his diligent and untiring efforts on behalf of Freemasonry has become this unofficial leader. I cannot speak to the management of the Grand Lodge of Florida, not being a member of that jurisdiction, nor can I speak to the management goals and imperatives of the two grand masters of Florida who tried to silence Wr. Bryce. However, one thing is clear: For every order a Grand Master of Florida issues to censor Wr. Bryce, the greater his notoriety grows.
Which begs the question: Why does Florida want to suppress his writings?
As noted above, within the boundaries of my obligation, it is hard to say. Wr. Bryce claims he has made enemies over the years who represent the "old-guard" and resist any attempt to change or modernize our fraternity. Change has a tendency to scare people, and Freemasonry is based on tradition, which is supposed to be unchanging, even when the "tradition" in question isn't really Masonic in nature.
Wr. Bryce, through his dissertations, seems to be frightening the Grand Lodge of Florida. His dissertation on the Masonic Necessity of all Mainstream Grand Lodges extending fraternal recognition to Prince Hall Masonry has touched off a discussion that is long past due in Florida. In return, the Grand Lodge of Florida is reacting to this threat by attempting to put an end to it... by silencing Wr. Bryce, using the rules of the fraternity he is bound by his obligations to obey.
The problem with all of this is Freemasonry, by its very tenets, stands for freedom of speech and freedom of thought. Keeping my obligations firmly in the front of my mind as I write this and examine the situation:
How can the Grand Lodge of Florida, in any way that can be considered within the framework of our tenets, justify the attempt to silence a brother for holding personal opinions and communicating them? Where would Henry Coil, Albert Mackey, Albert Pike, and Carl Claudy be if THEIR Grand Masters had silenced them? Or tied to.
I will leave you with one last thought: There is a legend about a certain Jewish Carpenter who was arrested for speaking against the existing temporal powers, convicted and executed. In his execution, a religion was born... The Grand Lodge of Florida might be well advised to consider a simple truth: a martyr's teachings carry more power than an unmolested teacher.
But I can write this. My Grand Lodge isn't trying to censor me.
Keep the Faith.
NOTE: The opinions expressed in this essay are my own and do not necessarily represent the views or opinions of any Grand Masonic jurisdiction or any other Masonic related body. As with all of my Masonic articles herein, please feel free to reuse them in Masonic publications or re-post them on Masonic web sites (except Florida). When doing so, please add the following:
Article reprinted with permission of the author and www.FreemasonInformation.com
Please forward me a copy of the publication when it is produced.
To receive notices of Tim's writings, subscribe to his Discussion Group.
You can also "tune in" to Bro. Tim's audio podcasts at the "Lodgeroom International" (UK):
http://podcast.lodgeroominternational.com/
Also be sure to check out Tim's "Pet Peeve of the Week" (non-Masonic related) at:
http://www.phmainstreet.com/timbryce.htm
Copyright © 2008 by Tim Bryce. All rights reserved.
Labels: Freemason, freemasonry, masonic, passing
Stumble It!